SILVER SPRING, Md. — The difference between medical device recalls and medical device enhancements is one that has confused lawyers and patients alike.

In the fall of 2014, the FDA issued its finalized guidance clarifying the distinction between medical device recalls and enhancements. This is a critical difference, because depending on which definition an update to a medical device falls under will determine reporting requirements. The new rule also clarified exactly what constitutes a recall.

The draft guidance from 2013 stated “as long as your change is initiated to reduce a risk to health posed by your device, even if your change is not a recall, you must submit an 806 report unless all the information has already been provided to FDA under the Medical Device Reporting requirements (21 C.F.R. Part 803).” The rule was envisioned to play out as such: 1) a manufacturer would disclose they were updating a device; 2) the FDA would review the report; and 3) the FDA would determine if it qualified as a recall.

The drug and device industry was extremely worried about this change because they believed it meant they had to report product enhancements beyond those that led to recalls. To get around these disclosure requirements, the manufacturers became heavily involved in the rule making process and offered feedback to the FDA. Now the rule creates a distinction between device enhancement and recall.

Recalls and Enhancements

Recalls are when a device needs to be corrected and removed. The key difference is whether the changes made to the device are intended to resolve a failure to meet certain specs or failure to perform as represented. This includes changes that are meant to deal with devices that are facing an increase in overall failure rate or single failure rate, or that identify a new situation in which the device might fail. Recalls are attempts to fix a problem in the device that would otherwise result in a violation of federal regulations.

Enhancements, on the other hand, are defined as changes to improve the performance or quality of the device, but these changes are not trying to fix something wrong with the device. Rather they are focused on making it more user friendly, easier to make, or improve non-critical safety or performance issues.

Going forward, this distinction matters to plaintiffs and victims of defective medical devices because this could arguably mean less information will be available to the FDA and consumers. Now, device manufacturers will try and claim changes to their product are being made for enhancement purposes, not to fix a critical or life-threatening issue, in order to avoid disclosing the change to the FDA. This may put consumers at risk and certainly flies in the face of transparency.

Our Defective Device Lawyers Can Help

Our dangerous device attorneys can help if you or someone you care about was harmed by defective medical device. Lawsuits have been filed against the device makers by both patients and their families seeking compensation for injuries caused by the dangerous device. You may be entitled to a settlement.

Our No Fee Promise on Defective Medical Devices

You can afford to have our great team of lawyers on your side. When you choose us, it costs nothing to get started. We promise you in writing:

  • No money to get started
  • We pay all case costs and expenses
  • No legal fees whatsoever unless you receive a settlement
  • Phone calls are always free

Start Your Defective Device Claim

Our defective device lawyers will help you file your lawsuit. To get started, you can:

  1. Submit the Free Case Review Box on this page, or
  2. Call (866) 280-4722 any time of the day to tell us about your case.

Warning: There are strict time deadlines for filing defective device lawsuit claims.

  • Was this information helpful?
  • Yes   No